Download: RSS | Email Alerts | Text Alerts | Mobile
 

Lottery conflicts plaintiff claims in $1 million ticket lawsuit


Story Comments Share
Reported by: David Goins
Tags:
Updated: 1/31/2012 5:43 pm Published: 1/31/2012 5:15 pm
BEEBE, AR - The Arkansas Scholarship Lottery weighs in on a dispute over a $1 million lottery ticket. What it says could change the outcome of the case and it’s a detail one side of the dispute doesn't want to talk about it.

Two sides feuding over a $1 million scratch off-ticket.

Sharon Jones found it, cashed it and got sued by Lisa Petriches, the store manager at the Super 1 Stop in Beebe.

Petriches claims Jones snatched it out of a store bin marked "do not take". Employee, clerk Rondi Smith testified to that in White County court last week.

Winston Collier represents Sharon Jones and maintains his client found the winning ticket in an unmarked bin and is the rightful recipient of the winnings.

However, when both sides informed circuit judge Thomas Hughes they would not finish presenting their case in a single day, the case was continued to a later date.

"We remain in that holding pattern at this point," Collier says.

No resolution yet but now the lottery is speaking out.

Arkansas Scholarship Lottery chief legal counsel Bishop Woosley released a statement regarding the supposed ticket bin.

“Lottery director of security Lance Huey and his deputy director Remmele Mazyck did not see any signs on or above the bin on the day following the claim for the prize being made,” Woosley says.

Based on the information we received from the Arkansas Lottery we decided to take it to the source who could perhaps answer the questions, Lisa Petriches.

Her claim to the $1 million prize might hinge on when the "do not take" sign showed up on the bin. So when we asked her about it Tuesday she quickly got on the phone and walked into her office.

Goins says: “The lottery says there was not a sign here. Are you denying what the lottery said? Are you saying the lottery is wrong?" Petriches says: "No comment."

The store even promotes the sale of a $1 million dollar ticket that so far no one can claim.

The store manager and her attorneys claim they know who rightfully bought the ticket.

That woman, Sharon Duncan, even testified last week she purchased the ticket and saw a “do not take” sign bin on the day she claims she bought it.

But the lottery maintains after looking at surveillance it can not say for sure who bought it, only who claimed it, Sharon Jones.

FOX16 spoke with Red Morgan, the attorney representing Petriches by phone on Tuesday. He said he has not made a decision on how to proceed but anticipates a decision soon.
Story Comments Share
13 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of FOX16 - Breaking News and Weather to Plan Your Day for Little Rock and Central Arkansas

sparrowhawk60 - 2/3/2012 10:12 AM
1 Vote
FACT is they threw it away!!!! Now just because it wins they want it back. Oh boo-hoo. Losers all the way around let the lady have the money. Would they want left-overs from lunch if someone else decided to eat them? The greedy people make me sick. Once you throw it away it means you don't want it anymore. Ask the police.

Monroe - 2/1/2012 10:01 PM
0 Votes
This is going to be a very exciting case. Some gotta win, some gotta lose, who, oh who, will the judge choose?

will26 - 2/1/2012 7:12 PM
2 Votes
Amen to that...major scum...

TheLastHuman - 2/1/2012 6:54 PM
2 Votes
Again the Supreme Court ruled some time ago that you can not discard something and lay claim to it at the same time back when people were still being arrested for dumpster diving and the note didn't show up on the bin until after I made a similar comment on the story before. Guess she figures the note would make it look less like it was being discarded and help her case, too bad the Lottery people noticed it wasn't there before. One word: SCUM!

zipede14 - 2/1/2012 1:10 PM
2 Votes
This is why you should scan your own tickets & not trust the store clerks to do it for you. The lady that actually bought the ticket should have asked to see the machine showing it wasnt a winner. I feel sorry for her because the store clerk basically stole the ticket from her when she told her it wasnt a winner & it was!

AZkidsmom - 2/1/2012 8:30 AM
2 Votes
The store is going to get a percentage. Plus I was under the impression that the store itself could not buy the tickets. Let the lady have her money and the store their percentage.

razbg - 2/1/2012 8:11 AM
1 Vote
According to the article in the Dem Gaz, Ms Duncan said that she scanned the ticket twice at the station and both times it told her it was not a winner. When the lottery was asked about this claim they said the winning ticket was scaned at the location it was purchased and two other locations and all three scanned showing it was a winning ticket. During the investigation on January 19th before the lottery paid out the money to Ms Jones the scanning machines were tested at the Beebe location and were in proper working order.

razbg - 2/1/2012 8:09 AM
1 Vote
As far as Ms Duncan and her knowing if she threw away the winning ticket according to the Dem Gaz article in testimony she said she scanned the ticket twice and it said it was a loser. When the Lottery was asked about this claim, they said the winning ticket was scanned at the location bought and two other locations each time showing it was a winner as expected. During their investigation before the pay out of the ticket the Beebe stores machine was checked and it was in working order.

alfisher3 - 2/1/2012 8:04 AM
5 Votes
The people in the town should boycott this store. It's obvious the owner is just a greedy liar who's upset that someone else received good fortune and she didn't. I hope the court awards the money to the lady that found the ticket. I guarantee if this was a losing ticket we wouldn't be hearing of this case today. So my hopes is that the judge and the lotto commission do the right thing and award the lady her money she found it fair and square.

thveleven - 2/1/2012 8:02 AM
1 Vote
In disputes like these, it's clear what to do: Give the winnings to me! :)
The links below are paid advertisements. FOX16 is not responsible for their content.
Current Conditions
69°
High: 81° | Low: 63°
Mostly Cloudy
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.